Pricing Resources Case Studies Blog Examples Contact
Log In
Blog

The Definitive Guide to Key Metrics for Evaluating Your Marketing Manager’s Campaigns Across Channels

In today's multi-channel marketing landscape, tracking the right metrics is essential to evaluate your marketing manager’s campaign effectiveness and maximize ROI. Each marketing channel—email, social media, PPC, content, and more—demands a specific set of KPIs to properly assess performance. Below is a comprehensive framework of key metrics to track across channels, enabling you to measure success, optimize strategies, and hold your marketing manager accountable.

1. Essential Universal Metrics for Cross-Channel Marketing Campaigns

These metrics apply to every marketing channel and provide a high-level view of campaign effectiveness.

1.1 Return on Investment (ROI)

What It Measures: The profitability of your marketing campaigns by comparing revenues generated against costs incurred.

Formula:
ROI = (Revenue from marketing - Marketing cost) / Marketing cost × 100%

Why It Matters:
ROI directly connects campaign investment to business outcomes, ensuring your marketing manager’s efforts contribute to the company’s bottom line.

Best Practices:

  • Use multi-touch attribution to allocate revenue accurately across channels (see Multi-Touch Attribution below).
  • Incorporate both direct and assisted conversions.
  • Regularly review ROI trends per channel to optimize budget allocation.

1.2 Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC)

What It Measures: The average expense to acquire one new customer.

Formula:
CAC = Total marketing spend / Number of new customers acquired

Why It Matters:
Tracking CAC per channel helps identify cost-efficient campaigns and ensures your acquisition cost aligns with customer lifetime value (LTV).

Best Practices:

  • Calculate CAC segmented by channel to reveal which campaigns deliver the best unit economics.
  • Combine CAC with LTV for sustainable growth insight.

1.3 Conversion Rate

What It Measures: Percentage of users completing a desired action (purchase, sign-up, download).

Formula:
Conversion Rate = (Number of conversions / Number of visitors or interactions) × 100%

Why It Matters:
Conversion rate reveals how compelling your campaign creatives and offers are in driving user actions.

Best Practices:

  • Define conversion goals specific to each campaign and channel (e.g., leads from social media, purchases from PPC).
  • Continuously optimize landing pages and calls-to-action (CTAs).

1.4 Click-Through Rate (CTR)

What It Measures: The ratio of users who clicked on your ad or campaign asset out of total impressions.

Formula:
CTR = (Clicks / Impressions) × 100%

Why It Matters:
CTR gauges ad relevance and creative effectiveness.

Best Practices:

  • Perform A/B testing on headlines, creatives, and targeting to improve CTR.
  • Benchmark CTR across channels to identify where audience interest is strongest.

1.5 Engagement Rate

What It Measures: Interaction rate indicating how audiences engage with your content (likes, shares, comments).

Formula:
Engagement Rate = (Total engagement actions / Total followers or impressions) × 100%

Why It Matters:
Engagement reflects content resonance and brand affinity, especially critical for social and content marketing channels.

Best Practices:

  • Measure engagement by content type and timing.
  • Combine engagement metrics with sentiment analysis to assess quality of interactions.

2. Channel-Specific Key Metrics

2.1 Email Marketing Metrics

  • Open Rate:={(Unique Opens / Emails Delivered) × 100%} — Indicates effectiveness of subject lines and sender reputation.
  • Click-to-Open Rate (CTOR):={(Unique Clicks / Unique Opens) × 100%} — Measures content relevance and CTA performance.
  • Bounce Rate:={(Bounced Emails / Emails Sent) × 100%} — Impacts deliverability and sender score.
  • Unsubscribe Rate: Tracks recipient disengagement signaling content or frequency issues.
  • Email Conversion Rate: Percentage of recipients completing campaign goals (purchases, registrations).

2.2 Social Media Metrics

  • Reach & Impressions: Unique users exposed and total views of your content.
  • Engagement Rate: As defined above, critical on platforms like Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn.
  • Follower Growth Rate: Tracks the speed of audience expansion.
  • Referral Traffic: Website visits originating from social platforms, measurable via UTM tags.
  • Conversion Rate from Social: Conversions attributed to social campaigns using pixel tracking or UTM parameters.

2.3 Paid Search & PPC Metrics

  • Quality Score: Google Ads metric evaluating ad relevance and landing page experience, affecting cost per click (CPC).
  • Cost per Click (CPC): Average amount paid per ad click.
  • Cost per Lead (CPL): Average cost to generate a lead via paid channels.
  • Impression Share: Share of available impressions your ads capture.
  • Conversion Rate & Cost per Conversion: Percent of clicks leading to conversions and associated cost.

2.4 Content Marketing Metrics

  • Organic Traffic: Visitors from unpaid search, important for SEO success.
  • Time on Page & Scroll Depth: Engagement quality indicating content relevance.
  • Backlinks & Domain Authority: SEO indicators reflecting content trustworthiness and ranking power.
  • Lead Generation: Gated content downloads or newsletter sign-ups driven by content.

3. Advanced Metrics: Multi-Touch Attribution & Assisted Conversions

Customers frequently interact with multiple channels before converting. Apply attribution models like linear, time decay, or position-based to properly credit each marketing touchpoint. Tracking assisted conversions provides visibility into how channels contribute to overall conversions beyond the last click. This ensures your evaluation of the marketing manager’s performance reflects the true impact of each channel and campaign.

4. Recommended Analytics Tools for Comprehensive Measurement

Implementing robust analytics tools is key to tracking and analyzing these metrics:

5. Best Practices for Using Marketing Metrics to Evaluate Campaign Effectiveness

5.1 Align Metrics to Campaign Goals

Define campaigns by their primary objectives (brand awareness, lead gen, revenue). Choose KPIs that directly map to those goals for accurate evaluation.

5.2 Segment and Drill Down into Data

Analyze performance segmented by channel, campaign, audience, and device to identify granular insights and areas for improvement.

5.3 Benchmark Against Past Performance and Industry Standards

Regular benchmarking contextualizes performance and sets realistic targets.

5.4 Automate Reporting with Dynamic Dashboards

Use tools like Google Data Studio or Tableau to visualize KPIs and enable quick, repeated evaluation across campaigns.

5.5 Continuously Test, Optimize, and Iterate

Leverage data-driven insights to run A/B tests, adjust targeting, refine messaging, and enhance creative assets.

6. Sample Multi-Channel Metrics Dashboard for Evaluating Your Marketing Manager’s Campaigns

Metric Email Social Media PPC Content Overall / Cross-Channel
Budget Spent $ $ $ $ $
Impressions
Clicks
CTR (%)
Conversions
Conversion Rate (%)
Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC)
Return on Investment (ROI) (%)
Engagement Rate (%) N/A
Bounce Rate
Customer Feedback Scores

Conclusion

To effectively evaluate your marketing manager's campaigns across multiple channels, prioritize tracking core metrics such as ROI, CAC, conversion rates, and engagement rates, alongside channel-specific KPIs. Integrating multi-touch attribution models ensures accurate crediting of revenue contributions. Leveraging powerful analytics platforms and feedback tools like Zigpoll enriches your understanding of campaign impact and guides continuous optimization.

By establishing a clear, data-driven metrics framework aligned to strategic goals, you empower your marketing manager to drive impactful, cost-efficient campaigns that deliver measurable business growth across all channels."

Start surveying for free.

Try our no-code surveys that visitors actually answer.
Get Started See Examples

Questions or Feedback?

We are always ready to hear from you.
Let's Talk
×