Pricing Resources Case Studies Blog Examples Contact
Log In
Blog

The Ultimate Guide: What Metrics to Focus on to Evaluate Your Ecommerce Marketing Agency

Choosing the right marketing agency to grow your ecommerce brand is critical, but equally important is knowing how to evaluate their performance effectively. Tracking the right metrics ensures your agency’s efforts translate into measurable growth, improved ROI, and sustainable customer relationships.

Here are the key ecommerce marketing metrics you should focus on to measure your agency’s effectiveness, optimize spending, and maximize revenue growth.

1. Return on Ad Spend (ROAS)

  • Why It Matters: ROAS measures how much revenue your marketing ads generate for every dollar spent. This directly reveals campaign profitability.
  • How to Calculate: ROAS = Revenue from Ad Campaign ÷ Cost of Ad Campaign
  • What to Monitor: Look for a ROAS above 4:1 as a healthy ecommerce benchmark. Track this metric over time to see if campaigns are improving. A declining ROAS signals inefficiencies your agency must address.

Learn more about ROAS in ecommerce.

2. Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC)

  • Why It Matters: CAC tells you how much it costs to gain a new customer. Balancing CAC with customer value is crucial for sustainable growth.
  • How to Calculate: CAC = Total Marketing Spend ÷ Number of Customers Acquired
  • What to Monitor: Ensure CAC stays below your customers’ Lifetime Value (LTV). Review CAC by channel and campaign to evaluate which marketing efforts deliver the best cost-efficiency.

Explore best practices on reducing CAC.

3. Customer Lifetime Value (LTV or CLTV)

  • Why It Matters: LTV estimates total revenue from a customer over their relationship with your brand. It helps decide optimal acquisition and retention budgets.
  • How to Calculate: LTV = Average Order Value × Purchase Frequency × Customer Lifespan
  • What to Monitor: Agencies should prioritize increasing LTV through retention and loyalty strategies, not just focus on acquiring one-time buyers. Compare LTV across channels to identify high-value customers.

Optimize LTV with strategies outlined at LTV calculation & growth.

4. Conversion Rate (CVR) from Marketing Channels

  • Why It Matters: Conversion Rate measures the percentage of visitors who make a purchase or complete desired actions, reflecting campaign relevance and site effectiveness.
  • How to Calculate: CVR = (Number of Conversions ÷ Number of Visitors) × 100
  • What to Monitor: Inspect conversion rates by channel, device, and demographics. An agency should continuously optimize targeting and messaging to improve CVR.

Understand how to boost your ecommerce conversion rate.

5. Average Order Value (AOV)

  • Why It Matters: AOV reveals customer purchasing behavior and directly impacts overall revenue.
  • How to Calculate: AOV = Total Revenue ÷ Number of Orders
  • What to Monitor: Encourage your agency to implement effective upselling, cross-selling, bundling, and loyalty programs to increase AOV over time.

Check strategies for increasing AOV in ecommerce.

6. Churn Rate

  • Why It Matters: Churn Rate signals the percentage of customers lost over time, providing insight into retention effectiveness.
  • How to Calculate: Churn Rate = (Number of Lost Customers ÷ Total Customers at Start) × 100
  • What to Monitor: A declining churn rate means your agency’s retention tactics (email marketing, retargeting, loyalty programs) are working well.

Read more about tracking ecommerce customer churn.

7. Traffic Quality Metrics

  • Why It Matters: High traffic volume means little unless visitors engage and convert.
  • Metrics to Track:
    • Bounce Rate: High bounce rates may indicate poor traffic targeting or user experience.
    • Pages Per Session & Session Duration: Higher values suggest engaging, relevant traffic.
  • What to Monitor: Assess traffic quality segmented by source—paid ads, organic search, social media—to evaluate how well the agency targets qualified leads.

For more on analyzing website traffic quality.

8. Attribution Accuracy

  • Why It Matters: Correctly attributing sales and conversions to marketing touchpoints ensures your budget focuses on effective channels.
  • What to Check: Is your agency using multi-touch attribution models instead of last-click only? Accurate attribution enables smarter spend allocation and better ROI.

Explore multi-touch attribution models.

9. Email Marketing Metrics

  • Why It Matters: If email is part of your marketing mix, these metrics reveal campaign effectiveness.
  • Key Metrics:
    • Open Rate
    • Click-Through Rate (CTR)
    • Unsubscribe Rate
    • Revenue Per Email
  • What to Monitor: Healthy open rates typically range from 15-25% with CTRs between 2-5%. High revenue per email indicates strong list monetization.

See current email marketing benchmarks.

10. Social Media Engagement and Conversion

  • Why It Matters: Social media should drive both brand awareness and sales, not just vanity metrics.
  • Key Metrics:
    • Engagement Rate (likes, shares, comments relative to followers)
    • Follower Growth
    • Click-Through Rate on posts and ads
    • Sales or leads generated directly through social channels
  • What to Monitor: Ensure engagement is organic and leads to conversions. Beware agencies that focus solely on likes without sales impact.

Understand how to measure social media ROI.

11. SEO Performance

  • Why It Matters: SEO builds sustainable organic traffic and long-term growth.
  • Critical SEO Metrics:
    • Organic Traffic Growth
    • Keyword Rankings Improvements
    • Domain Authority & Backlink Quality
    • Organic Conversions
  • What to Monitor: Expect steady improvement with white-hat SEO tactics to avoid penalties. Organic traffic should convert competitively with paid traffic.

Learn about measuring SEO success.

12. Ad Creative and Campaign Testing Metrics

  • Why It Matters: Constant A/B and multivariate testing refine messaging and offers to maximize campaign effectiveness.
  • What to Monitor: Frequency of tests, improvements in CTR, CVR, and cost-efficiency. Agencies should provide transparent insights and adapt strategies based on data.

Guide to A/B testing for ecommerce.

13. Customer Satisfaction and Brand Sentiment

  • Why It Matters: Happy customers and strong brand reputation drive repeat business and organic referrals.
  • Key Metrics:
    • Online Reviews and Ratings
    • Social Listening for Brand Mentions and Sentiment
    • Net Promoter Score (NPS)
  • What to Monitor: Ensure your agency supports positive brand sentiment and addresses negative feedback promptly.

Track brand sentiment with tools like Brandwatch.

14. Cost per Click (CPC) and Cost per Mille (CPM)

  • Why It Matters: CPC and CPM benchmark ad spend efficiency and scale.
  • What to Monitor: Aim for decreasing or consistent CPC/CPM as campaigns scale. Rising costs often mean poor targeting or creative issues.

Learn more about CPC and CPM efficiency.

15. Fulfillment and Customer Service Feedback

  • Why It Matters: Your agency’s messaging should align with fulfillment and service teams to ensure a seamless customer experience.
  • What to Monitor: Customer feedback collected via marketing channels detailing delivery, support, and product satisfaction.

Implement Transparent Reporting and Dashboards

A top marketing agency provides transparent, real-time reporting accessible through dashboards like Zigpoll for collecting customer feedback alongside performance data. This qualitative insight can reveal why customers purchase or churn, giving you a fuller picture of agency impact.

Common Pitfalls When Evaluating Your Agency

  • Avoid Vanity Metrics: Don’t be swayed by likes, impressions, or follower counts without conversion context.
  • Demand Accurate Attribution: Don’t rely on last-click-only metrics.
  • Prioritize Retention: New customers cost more—retention metrics are essential.
  • Incorporate Qualitative Data: Customer surveys and reviews add depth to numbers.

Summary Table: Focus on These Metrics to Evaluate Your Ecommerce Marketing Agency

Category Key Metrics
Revenue Efficiency ROAS, CAC, LTV
Conversion & Engagement Conversion Rate, Bounce Rate, Session Duration
Order Value & Retention AOV, Churn Rate
Traffic & Channel Quality Traffic Quality (Bounce Rate, Pages/Session), Attribution, CPC, CPM
Channel-Specific Performance Email Metrics, Social Media Engagement, SEO
Creative & Testing Ad Testing Results
Brand & Customer Insight Customer Satisfaction, Brand Sentiment, NPS

Effectively evaluating your ecommerce marketing agency requires a balanced focus on revenue-driving KPIs and customer-centric metrics. Regularly track these indicators, discuss them openly with your agency, and use tools like Zigpoll to enhance feedback loops. This approach ensures your agency is accountable, optimizes marketing spend, and drives profitable ecommerce growth.

Happy optimizing and scaling your ecommerce brand!

Start surveying for free.

Try our no-code surveys that visitors actually answer.
Get Started See Examples

Questions or Feedback?

We are always ready to hear from you.
Let's Talk
×