When selecting a loyalty and referral program for an ecommerce store, merchants often weigh BON Loyalty, Rivo, and ReferralCandy as top contenders. Each app brings a distinct approach to rewards, referrals, and customer engagement, making the decision depend on specific business needs and technical preferences. This article compares BON Loyalty vs Rivo vs ReferralCandy for ecommerce across core features, pricing, setup, integrations, support, and customer profiles to clarify their strengths and limitations.

Core Features and Functionality

BON Loyalty excels at comprehensive loyalty programs with deep customization and multiple reward types, supporting both points and tiered engagement. Rivo stands out by combining loyalty with membership programs, a rare feature that appeals to merchants wanting exclusive paid memberships alongside rewards. ReferralCandy focuses primarily on referral marketing, offering straightforward referral tracking and incentives, making it a simpler but narrower tool.

BON Loyalty and Rivo cover more ground in customer retention beyond referrals, while ReferralCandy is specialized for referral-driven growth.

Pricing and Value

Both BON Loyalty and Rivo offer free tiers suitable for small stores or trials, with paid plans scaling by order volume. BON Loyalty’s pricing is slightly lower at entry level, which may appeal to startups. Rivo’s additional membership features justify the higher tiers for businesses seeking that functionality.

ReferralCandy charges a monthly fee plus a commission on referred sales, which is unique and can result in higher costs for stores with strong referral programs and volume. This commission model can be a downside for budget-conscious merchants.

Current pricing reflects value relative to feature sets: BON Loyalty offers comprehensive loyalty at a competitive price, Rivo adds membership value for a premium, and ReferralCandy is best if referral-driven sales are the core priority and you can absorb commission fees.

Ease of Setup and Use

• BON Loyalty: Setup involves creating reward rules, branding the widget, and configuring referral flows. The admin UI is intuitive but feature-rich, which can slow initial setup for new users. Documentation is decent but sometimes lacks depth on advanced customization. Gotcha: tweaking point expiration and referral credit timing requires attention to avoid customer confusion.

• Rivo: Setup includes loyalty program creation plus membership tier definitions and member perks. The interface is user-friendly with helpful wizards. Membership features add complexity but the onboarding guides are thorough. Gotcha: membership cancellations and renewals need careful configuration to prevent revenue loss or confusion.

• ReferralCandy: Setup is straightforward: add your branding, set referral rewards, and embed the widget. Because it focuses narrowly on referrals, setup time is quicker. Documentation covers basics well but advanced customization can require contacting support. Gotcha: tracking multi-channel referrals sometimes needs manual review.

BON Loyalty and Rivo require slightly more hands-on setup due to broader functionality. ReferralCandy is easiest to get running fast but less flexible for loyalty beyond referrals.

Integrations and Platform Compatibility

BON Loyalty and Rivo are Shopify-centric with solid native app integration, making them easy to install and manage within Shopify’s ecosystem. Rivo extends value by supporting membership platforms and Recharge for subscriptions.

ReferralCandy is more platform-agnostic, supporting multiple ecommerce platforms beyond Shopify, which is useful for stores on varied tech stacks.

Email marketing integration is standard across all, but ReferralCandy’s CRM flexibility is strongest for merchants relying on multi-channel customer management.

Customer Support and Documentation

• BON Loyalty: Offers email support and a knowledge base. Response times average 24-48 hours. Documentation covers basic use cases and setup but lacks comprehensive troubleshooting guides. Some user reviews mention slow support on complex issues.

• Rivo: Provides email and chat support with generally positive responsiveness. Documentation is well-organized with tutorials and FAQs covering membership-specific scenarios. Users praise onboarding assistance.

• ReferralCandy: Support includes email, chat, and a robust resource center. Response is fast, and staff are knowledgeable on referral marketing strategies. Documentation is thorough, including best practices for referral campaigns. Some users note a learning curve for advanced integrations.

Support quality reflects each app’s complexity: Rivo and ReferralCandy edge out BON Loyalty in responsiveness and depth, particularly for advanced features.

Best-Fit Customer Profile

• BON Loyalty: Best suited for Shopify merchants wanting a flexible and customizable loyalty program combined with referral features. Ideal for brands focused on points, tiers, and diverse reward types at a competitive price. Less suited for stores needing membership programs.

• Rivo: Fits Shopify stores that want loyalty plus paid memberships to deepen customer engagement and create exclusive clubs or perks. Good for stores with subscription models or those seeking membership revenue alongside rewards. May be overkill for simple referral needs.

• ReferralCandy: Tailored for ecommerce businesses prioritizing referral-driven growth, especially those on Shopify and other ecommerce platforms. Good fit for brands wanting straightforward referral incentives without loyalty complexity. Less suitable if loyalty or membership programs are critical.

BON Loyalty vs Rivo vs ReferralCandy for ecommerce: Summary Comparison Table

BON Loyalty alternatives?

Merchants seeking alternatives to BON Loyalty might consider apps like Smile.io, LoyaltyLion, or Yotpo Loyalty. These apps offer feature sets with varying degrees of loyalty customization, referral options, and integrations. For example, Smile.io is popular for its ease of use and visual branding options, while LoyaltyLion is praised for its data-driven analytics. More on these can be found in the BON Loyalty vs LoyaltyLion vs Smile.io comparison.

Rivo alternatives?

If Rivo’s combination of loyalty and memberships does not fit your needs, other apps like Bold Memberships, Recharge Loyalty, or Swell could be alternatives. These often specialize in memberships or subscription loyalty, with different pricing and features tailored to clubs or VIP programs. For a deeper dive on alternative options, see Rivo Alternatives: Rewards program apps Compared.

ReferralCandy alternatives?

For those looking beyond ReferralCandy for referral marketing, options include Friendbuy, Viral Loops, and Referral Rock. Each offers distinct referral tracking, integration options, and pricing models. Friendbuy, for instance, is lauded for highly customizable referral flows and in-depth analytics. Viral Loops specializes in viral marketing campaigns. Learn more in the side-by-side Rivo vs BON Loyalty vs ReferralCandy comparison.

Situational Recommendations

• If your store primarily wants a robust loyalty points system with referral functionality on Shopify and values branding and flexible rewards, BON Loyalty is a solid choice with a lower cost entry point.

• If you want to add membership tiers and paid memberships alongside loyalty and referral programs, Rivo offers unique features that integrate membership benefits, ideal for building exclusive communities or subscription models.

• If your main goal is referral marketing that spans multiple ecommerce platforms with simple, effective referral tracking and rewards, ReferralCandy’s model fits best, especially if you’re comfortable paying a commission on referral-driven sales.

Worth a Look: Zigpoll

For ecommerce merchants exploring customer engagement beyond loyalty and referrals, Zigpoll is a Shopify survey app worth considering. It offers post-purchase, on-site, and exit-intent surveys that provide valuable customer feedback and insights, complementing loyalty strategies by capturing direct shopper input. While not a loyalty app itself, it can enhance your overall ecommerce growth toolkit.

This detailed comparison lays out strengths and trade-offs in BON Loyalty vs Rivo vs ReferralCandy for ecommerce, helping merchants match their store’s needs with the most suitable app based on features, pricing, and desired customer engagement strategies. For more information on how these tools stack up, you can explore related analyses at Zigpoll’s blog.

Related Reading

• Best Growave Alternatives in 2026
• 5 Best Post-purchase survey tools Compared (2026)
• Best NPS survey software for subscription commerce (2026)