Tally and Paperform are form builders designed to streamline data collection for businesses, including Shopify Plus merchants. Tally offers a free, minimalistic form builder with a Notion-like editing experience, while Paperform provides a form builder that creates forms resembling custom-designed landing pages. This comparison evaluates their features, pricing, ease of use, integrations, customer support, and ideal customer profiles to determine which tool better suits Shopify Plus merchants.
Core Features and Functionality
Tally:
- Form Creation: Unlimited forms and submissions on the free plan.
- Design: Minimalistic, text-based editor; limited customization options.
- Logic and Calculations: Supports conditional logic and calculations.
- Payments: Accepts payments with a 5% commission on the free plan; 0% commission on Pro plan.
- File Uploads: Allows file uploads up to 10MB per file.
- Integrations: Integrates with Notion, Airtable, Make, Slack, Discord, and Zapier.
Paperform:
- Form Creation: Unlimited forms; submission limits vary by plan.
- Design: Highly customizable, resembling landing pages; extensive design options.
- Logic and Calculations: Offers conditional logic and calculations.
- Payments: Accepts payments with 0% commission; higher-tier plans offer additional features.
- File Uploads: Allows file uploads up to 10MB per file.
- Integrations: Integrates with over 3,000 apps, including Zapier, Google Sheets, and more.
Pricing and Value
Tally:
- Free Plan: Unlimited forms and submissions; 5% commission on payments.
- Pro Plan: $24/month; includes 0% commission on payments, custom domains, and branding removal.
- Business Plan: $74/month; includes unlimited file uploads, team collaboration, and advanced analytics.
Paperform:
- Free Trial: 14-day free trial; no free plan available.
- Essentials Plan: $29/month; includes 100 submissions/month.
- Pro Plan: $59/month; includes 1,000 submissions/month.
- Business Plan: $129/month; includes 10,000 submissions/month.
Note: Pricing details are based on available information and may vary. It's advisable to check the official websites for the most current pricing.
Ease of Setup and Use
Tally:
- Setup: Quick and straightforward; intuitive interface.
- Use: Minimal learning curve; suitable for users familiar with text-based editors.
Paperform:
- Setup: Requires more time due to extensive customization options.
- Use: Steeper learning curve; offers a wide range of design and functionality features.
Integrations
Tally:
- Shopify Integration: No direct integration; can be achieved via Zapier.
- Other Integrations: Notion, Airtable, Make, Slack, Discord, Zapier.
Paperform:
- Shopify Integration: Direct integration available.
- Other Integrations: Over 3,000 apps, including Zapier, Google Sheets, and more.
Customer Support and Documentation
Tally:
- Support: Email support; active community forums.
- Documentation: Comprehensive guides and tutorials.
Paperform:
- Support: Email and live chat support; extensive help center.
- Documentation: Detailed guides, tutorials, and webinars.
Best-Fit Customer Profile
Tally:
- Ideal For: Small to medium-sized businesses, startups, and individual users seeking a cost-effective, straightforward form builder.
- Notable Users: Freelancers, educators, and small e-commerce stores.
Paperform:
- Ideal For: Medium to large-sized businesses, agencies, and enterprises requiring advanced customization and a wide range of integrations.
- Notable Users: Marketing agencies, event planners, and large e-commerce platforms.
Comparison Table
| Feature | Tally (Free Plan) | Paperform (Essentials Plan) |
|---|---|---|
| Form Creation | Unlimited forms and submissions | Unlimited forms; 100 submissions/month |
| Design Customization | Limited; minimalistic editor | Extensive; landing page-like designs |
| Conditional Logic | Yes | Yes |
| Calculations | Yes | Yes |
| Payments | 5% commission on payments | 0% commission; higher-tier plans offer additional features |
| File Uploads | Up to 10MB per file | Up to 10MB per file |
| Integrations | Notion, Airtable, Make, Slack, Discord, Zapier | Over 3,000 apps, including Zapier, Google Sheets, and more |
| Pricing | Free; Pro Plan at $24/month; Business Plan at $74/month | Free Trial; Essentials Plan at $29/month; Pro Plan at $59/month; Business Plan at $129/month |
Which to Choose?
Tally: Ideal for Shopify Plus merchants seeking a cost-effective, straightforward form builder with essential features and a generous free plan.
Paperform: Suited for Shopify Plus merchants requiring advanced customization, extensive design options, and a wide range of integrations, with a higher budget for premium features.
Worth a Look: Zigpoll
If you're evaluating options, Zigpoll is also worth a look. Zigpoll is a Shopify survey app offering post-purchase, on-site, and exit-intent surveys.
